City audit finds lax funding oversight of Westside business enterprise team
Table of Contents
An internal audit discovered that San Antonio’s Financial Advancement Department did not sufficiently keep track of its funding agreement with a nonprofit company advancement group with near ties to the city.
Prosper West, previously the Westside Advancement Corporation, submitted incorrect quarterly experiences, awarded a grant to an ineligible business enterprise, did not meet its matching fund specifications and did not return $53,500 in unspent money to the town, in accordance to the audit, performed from April to August. The metropolis auditor’s results had been forwarded to Metropolis Council on Sept. 26 by means of a memo.
The mission of Prosper West is to foster economic expansion and business enterprise improvement on the city’s West Aspect, furnishing grants, steerage and other solutions to modest enterprises.
As portion of its fiscal yr 2023 funding agreement with Prosper West, the metropolis delivered the nonprofit with two pots of revenue: $100,000 in economic advancement incentive funds, used to supply financial guidance to compact corporations, and approximately $259,000 in typical funds for operations.
Brenda Hicks-Sorensen, executive director of the Financial Growth Department, informed City Council users for the duration of the Oct. 10 audit committee conference that her department accepted the audit’s results and had started producing a thorough agreement monitoring strategy, to be overseen by a compliance group headed up by a new supervisor with longtime compliance skills.
Department staff fulfilled with Prosper West President and CEO Ramiro Gonzales and its interim board chair and vice chair to assessment the audit’s findings. Hicks-Sorensen informed the San Antonio Report on Tuesday that the section is doing the job carefully with leadership to deliver the corporation into compliance with the deal and make absolutely sure the remaining dollars is dispersed to small corporations with the appropriate documentation.
“Brenda, no offense, but I assume your office genuinely fell down on the task with this one,” explained Councilman John Braveness (D9). “But I’m happy to listen to there is a system to take care of this … with improved checking.”
Casual ‘workarounds’
Gonzales, who has headed Prosper West given that 2020, confirmed the business is working with the section staff to handle the audit’s conclusions and reported he also hopes the audit gives an opportunity to update the settlement so that it much better serves both equally parties.
It has been difficult for Prosper West to comply with selected facets of the city’s funding agreement, he explained, in section mainly because of delays obtaining the annual arrangement from the metropolis. As soon as that is signed, it even now takes a when for the income to movement, he stated. These delays put tension on the corporation to disperse revenue within the fiscal year, which finishes Sept. 30. Casual “workarounds” had been the norm, he explained, “for as very long as I’ve been below.”
“It’s essential to be aware that Prosper West will get an outdoors audit each individual yr, and we get a clean audit each individual yr,” he reported. The conclusions from city’s audit are “more about the timing of how factors are having completed.”
For example, he explained, the audit found that in Prosper West’s fourth-quarter 2022 report to the town, it documented 15 financial loans and grants made to neighborhood modest corporations. The audit observed that in that time interval, it experienced built only 4. Gonzales stated that’s simply because some of people financial loans and grants came from past fiscal yr funding allotments.
Gonzales explained Prosper West is normally a source of very last vacation resort for modest corporations, who will need handholding to get to the place where by Prosper West can situation a grant or financial loan. “It can take months,” he stated.
Other audit results really do not seem to be relevant to any time factor. Auditors observed that the business did not continue to keep the city’s revenue in a independent account as essential by the arrangement and that it did not offer auditors adequate documentation all over the grants and loans it has dispersed.
Hicks-Sorensen instructed the audit committee that Prosper West appeared to have some “exceptions to their policies … that just weren’t documented appropriately.” She explained the department would do a “detailed overview of their policies” ahead of a new funding arrangement was established.
She also mentioned that the metropolis did not grant Prosper West any further economic incentive resources for fiscal yr 2024, which started on Oct. 1, so that the office can observe the disbursement of the remaining $53,500 from fiscal 12 months 2023, a lot of which has been earmarked for corporations Prosper West is by now doing the job with.
Last year’s funding agreement expired on Sept. 30 of this year, and the division has but to hammer out new arrangement for fiscal yr 2024. Hicks-Sorensen informed the audit committee the division is doing the job with the finance section, city attorney’s business and auditors “to assure those people contracts are certainly express.”
She told the San Antonio Report the department’s 1st priority is to abide by up on the audit tips and acquire those people back again to Town Council. “Then, based on people discussions and opinions,” a new deal will be created and taken to again to council for acceptance.
‘Significant conversations’
The Economic Improvement Department took around administration of the city’s deal with the Westside Progress Corporation in 2020 from the Center City Advancement & Operations Department Hicks-Sorensen joined the office in 2021. She informed the audit committee that prior to the audit the division had had “significant conversations” all over contract management and compliance, obligations that had been “scattered all over the department.”
Findings from the audit will be utilised to assessment all of the department’s annual funding agreements with organization progress companies, which contains San Antonio Progress for the Eastside (SAGE) and Southside First Economic Improvement Council.
The broad mission of these organizations is financial enhancement within the geographic confines of every group’s assistance spot, all of which have traditionally suffered from neglect, disinvestment, superior poverty and reduced educational attainment.
Prosper West is exclusive in that it was formed by the city as a local enhancement corporation in 2006, to aid spur financial revitalization via land redevelopment on the West Facet, a lot as Brooks and Port San Antonio have performed with previous armed forces foundation property. But the town never ever conveyed property to the Westside Improvement Company, and it never ever experienced the sources to get land.
Mainly because it is even now a regional development company, nonetheless, the metropolis continue to appoints the board, and Prosper West is not suitable for selected outside the house economical support simply because of its standing as a quasi-governmental agency, or what Hicks-Sorensen known as a “component device of the city.”
In 2021, the WDC adjusted its identify to Prosper West the rebrand was intended to emphasis on the complete company and true estate ecosystem on the West Aspect and operate as “an organization exactly where individuals want to plug in and be element of that transformation,” Gonzales claimed at the time.
As element of that hard work, Prosper West, in partnership with the DreamOn Group, is redeveloping the Basila Frocks creating at 500 N. Zarzamora St. The objective is to home little and emerging corporations, as very well as to create an further earnings stream for the organization.
Gonzales stated there has been some dialogue all-around separating Prosper West from the town so that it operated far more like other nearby business enterprise advancement teams. All those discussions have not gotten to the nuts and bolts of how that may transpire.
Hicks-Sorensen mentioned anything at all that aids aid and fortify companies like Prosper West will in the end assistance area tiny businesses. “And that is actually the city’s conclude purchaser.”
This write-up has been up-to-date to reflect that the city’s funding arrangement with Prosper West expired on Sept. 30 of this calendar year. An audit report improperly mentioned the ending date.